Rxivist logo

Inward and outward effectiveness of cloth masks, a surgical mask, and a face shield

By Jin Pan, Charbel Harb, Weinan Leng, Linsey C. Marr

Posted 20 Nov 2020
medRxiv DOI: 10.1101/2020.11.18.20233353

We evaluated the effectiveness of 11 face coverings for material filtration efficiency, inward protection efficiency on a manikin, and outward protection efficiency on a manikin. At the most penetrating particle size, the vacuum bag, microfiber cloth, and surgical mask had material filtration efficiencies >50%, while the other materials had much lower filtration efficiencies. However, these efficiencies increased rapidly with particle size, and many materials had efficiencies >50% at 2 m and >75% at 5 m. The vacuum bag performed best, with efficiencies of 54-96% for all three metrics, depending on particle size. The thin acrylic and face shield performed worst. Inward protection efficiency and outward protection efficiency were similar for many masks; the two efficiencies diverged for stiffer materials and those worn more loosely (e.g., bandana) or more tightly (e.g., wrapped around the head) compared to a standard earloop mask. Discrepancies between material filtration efficiency and inward/outward protection efficiency indicated that the fit of the mask was important. We calculated that the particle size most likely to deposit in the respiratory tract when wearing a mask is [~]2 m. Based on these findings, we recommend a three-layer mask consisting of outer layers of a flexible, tightly woven fabric and an inner layer consisting of a material designed to filter out particles. This combination should produce an overall efficiency of >70% at the most penetrating particle size and >90% for particles 1 m and larger if the mask fits well.

Download data

  • Downloaded 7,048 times
  • Download rankings, all-time:
    • Site-wide: 1,105
    • In public and global health: 46
  • Year to date:
    • Site-wide: 504
  • Since beginning of last month:
    • Site-wide: 96

Altmetric data


Downloads over time

Distribution of downloads per paper, site-wide


PanLingua

Sign up for the Rxivist weekly newsletter! (Click here for more details.)


News